What is Acceptance and Commitment Therapy?
Acceptance and commitment therapy (ACT) is a relatively new form of psychotherapy, pioneered by Steven C. Hayes in the mid 1990s. It is an outgrowth of behavioral therapy and cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT), which has largely been the accepted method for treatment of conditions like depression, anxiety, and post-traumatic stress disorders. ACT, like CBT, relies on the philosophy of functional contextualism, a school of thought suggesting that words and ideas can only be understood within context and are, therefore, frequently misconstrued because people have individual contexts. Another influence is relational frame therapy, a form of behavioral analysis examining language and learning.
CBT focuses on identifying “hot thoughts” when in the throes of an anxiety attack or deep depression, and then evaluating such thoughts to gauge how true they really are. For example, a person who is feeling unduly anxious might evaluate a thought like, “Everybody hates me,” and then list evidence as to why this is or is not true. After looking at the underlying thoughts that cause anxiety, a person evaluates whether his or her stress has been reduced. The process seems long, but after a while, people can adeptly work this process in their head, understanding that these thoughts occur but are not representative of what is really “true”. When such thoughts develop in the future, they can be dismissed after training in CBT.
Acceptance and commitment therapy differs from CBT because it immediately accepts the thought, “Everybody hates me.” The thought is viewed without passion, and the statement is sometimes verbalized as, “I am having the thought that everybody hates me.” This may be repeated until the thought is defused. Hayes recognizes about 100 defusion techniques.
Previous unwanted thoughts are not actively dismissed by the person undergoing this form of therapy but are rather embraced. This is also distinctive from CBT because that therapy aims to reduce unwanted and unhelpful thoughts. ACT therapists claim that the process of their therapy takes far less time and is, therefore, more effective.
Mindfulness and being present in daily living and thoughts are particularly stressed in acceptance and commitment therapy. It also aims to help people identify their set of inner values. This therapy focuses on choosing behaviors that accord with these values, placing emphasis on things that can be controlled, like the set of the mouth, the rapidity of breaths, or the way the person's arms and legs move.
ACT prides itself on its empirical data, and since 1996, about 20 clinical studies have assessed its effectiveness in varied situations that require psychological intervention. So far, Hayes' claims have been supported by clinical trials. Proving these claims empirically requires more study, however, and it is sometimes a means by which other therapists reject them. To claim a theory is empirically proven, a far greater number of clinical trials must be conducted.
Currently, Hayes and other proponents of acceptance and commitment therapy teach their methods in workshops around the world. These workshops tend to be two to three days in length. Universities offering degrees in psychology and counseling commonly devote a class to this method and other third-wave behavioral therapies.
@EarlyForest: I actually think ACT doesn't do enough to address mental illness or dispassionate viewing of very strong emotions. That takes greater work.
Actually, I think the answers are found in Buddhism, from which, ACT takes so much. Pema Chodron does a very good job talking about living in and with pain and she's really approachable to non-Buddhists.
ACT does have some lovely applications, but as a theory, I don't think it's perfect. But then, what is?
@EarlyForest -- I think what you're asking is how can people who are in a state where they may find it hard to view their thoughts dispassionately just accept and verbalize so called "hot thoughts."
I assume that kind of comes with training and practice.
ACT also has a lot of emphasis on mindful action, which I imagine helps a lot of people get out of that "wheel-spinning" mentality where they just get stuck with their thoughts.
How does this treatment deal with the fact that many people, particularly when anxious or depressed, have a hard time viewing things dispassionately?
That actually sounds a lot like meditation -- the emphasis on mindfulness, and on viewing thoughts dispassionately, without judging them.
Many meditation leaders will actually advise people to view their thoughts like that, to "step back" from their stream of thought, so to say, while meditating.
Post your comments